Saturday, 21 November 2009

Train whistleblowin'...and the smoking gun...

...further to the leaked documents saga. From blogger Tom Nelson...There's a storm brewing on the Web over e-mails that hackers got hold of in which some scientists at one of the world's leading research centers say things such as the need to "hide the decline" in data about temperatures. Skeptics who have doubts about whether humans are contributing to global warming are pouncing on the revelations.I think a leaker is more likely than a hacker, but find out who to thank in due course. For now, the folks at Hadley (and Michael Mann) are trying to deflect attention from what they wrote to each other by focusing on the legality of how the papers were obtained.This is now being taken up by the MSM worldwide...Tony soprano had some excellent words of wisdom for the motley CRU: “You can’t put the shit back in the donkey.” ...If true, it would seem that being “effective” will have taken precedence over being honest. If true, this could be one of the largest scientific frauds ever perpetrated. Given the impact that this and related climate research has had on climate policy, the world economy, energy generation, and specifically the coal industry, such a revelation would be devastating for climate research as a whole....
UK Guardian...
Sean Hannity...
The Wall St. Journal...
UK Telegraph...

The BBC...
Fox News...
The Australian...
The NY Times...
...from Michelle Malkin... The global warming scandal of the century...
...from Pajamas Media...But then, the whole package is very large — 63 megabytes — and seems to be very internally consistent. Several people have already corroborated a number of the emails as being ones they wrote or received. The package also includes substantial data and computer programs, which are being explored as this is being written.
The best we can say right now is that we should keep our eyes on this. If these files are eventually corroborated and verified, it is a bombshell indeed — evidence that there has been a literal conspiracy to push the anthropogenic climate change agenda far beyond the science.
It will mean the end of some scientific careers, and it might even mean those careers will end in jail.

...and a little bit of levity, with compliments to Neil, posting at WuWT...all together now...
“With those that cry “warm!”, I will differ.
There is Mann, there is Jones, there is Briffa.
Mike’s hockey stick’s junk,
Phil’s data did a bunk, (? got sunk)
And Keith got caught out by a sniffer.”

...I'm about to knock off for a while, but this comment sums it all up very well indeed...
...In preparing cases for court I look at reams of documents each working week and I must say that there are only a few documents that resemble a smoking gun. The most significant scientifically is the one which says “we are nowhere close to knowing where energy is going”. This blasts a big hole in any statement that CO2 is CAUSING anything, and leaves the alarmists with mere correlation at best. Without a causal relationship they have proven nothing other than a need for more research. Collectively, however, the documents show a pattern that, far from testing their hypotheses, these people are actively seeking to overcome each and every inconvenient fact in their quest to manufacture an unequivocal outcome. In the process they add layers of assumption onto layers of assumption and create a veritable house of cards. The IPCC report in the end became so elaborate and flimsy that Kevin Rudd’s spin squad would be proud...more here...

5 comments:

Nessa said...

“You can’t put the shit back in the donkey.” I love this.

Deflection is the best defense.

Flash 55 - Favors

Ayrdale said...

"If true, it would seem that being “effective” will have taken precedence over being honest. If true, this could be one of the largest scientific frauds ever perpetrated. Given the impact that this and related climate research has had on climate policy, the world economy, energy generation, and specifically the coal industry, such a revelation would be devastating for climate research as a whole."

F***ing incredible so far...

Anonymous said...

Imagine if the roles were reversed and a lefty journalist had uncovered emails from the the sceptical side squashing/obliterating data. Front page news everywhere.

This has got to become widely known. This is the smoking gun.

twawki said...

Lets see if all their finger pointing comes back on them and they get what they wished upon the 'skeptics'

Ayrdale said...

It is certainly a miserable time to be writing a green left blog like Hot Topic.

And on the other hand, I've had a great day !